I had a wonderful visit with a new client and her puppy earlier this week. She's never had a dog of her own before, though she grew up with dogs. Like many of the young people I meet, she was never responsible for anything with regard to those family dogs, other than love, attention, and an occasional walk! Because she wants "to do everything right," she decided to meet with me in person for a "Puppy 101" appointment. I've talked about my Puppy 101 appointments before; I basically give you a crash course in puppies, their wants and needs, the importance of establishing good routines early, boundaries (literal and figurative), selecting the right toys, leashes, and bedding, etc. One of the main things I go over right off the bat is the value in having a crate (or two) in your home.
Believe it or not, crate training a dog isn't something new. The first dog crate was patented in the early 1900's and they were used extensively with police and military canines. Using crates to recreate denning behavior and help with house training, for example, really took hold during the 1980's as an emphasis on positive training practices rather than aversives was emphasized. Popularized by Dr. Ian Dunbar in the mid-80's while he was teaching volunteers and staff at the San Francisco SPCA, crate training puppies and dogs became more of a standard of practice and widely accepted as a helpful tool in the pursuit of happily house trained dogs.
Crate training isn't a complete no-brainer, however. You do need to put some thought into the style of crate you use, the size, the placement, amount of time you use it, and what you use it for. I prefer crates to be placed in a bedroom where at least one of the humans sleeps. That bedroom can easily be a kid's bedroom, as long as said child is capable of being responsible for responding to a puppy who indicates it needs to use the bathroom in the middle of the night! Puppies gain social time with us even when we are asleep when they snooze in our bedrooms with us. Crates in bedrooms are also ideal for those very important daily, scheduled naps. Most of us don't use our bedrooms during the daytime making them ideal locations for puppies to nap and learn that it's okay to be alone for a little while every day. You will want to establish good sleep rituals from the get go, closing curtains or blinds, and using fans, white noise machines, or music as background noise to make resting during the day easier for your puppy. I'm not a fan of putting covers on crates as I think they restrict air flow. Instead, I suggest a soft, durable bed for the crate, a crate pad, or a cuddler bed that will curl up around a small dog or puppy for stress relief and comfort. I love wire crates as again, good air flow. Plus, they often come with dividers which allow you to adjust the size of the crate as your puppy grows. I know people who swear by airline style crates, and some who love nylon, tent-style crates. For me, airline crates in my house are icky to look at and since I use crates on and off for my dogs' entire lifetimes, I don't want something ugly in my home! I love nylon crates for travel, but I just don't find them durable for long term use indoors, especially for puppies who like to chew on the zippers and seams for fun!
So, you might be asking, how long can a puppy be in a crate? A good rule of thumb is one hour in the crate per month of life, plus one. So, a three month old puppy like the one I saw this week could be in the crate for up to four hours at a time. Given that most puppies nap two to three hours at a time, this works great. They do that nap in their crate, come out for a bathroom break, play time, a snack and some training, and then head back a couple hours later for another nap. Don't worry about that three month old puppy crating for longer than four hours at night. That rule of thumb applies to daytime sleep primarily. Adult dogs can crate for longer, but really a dog should not be in a crate during the daytime for longer than eight hours. If your work schedule has you crating your dog for more than eight hours, consider doggie daycare for them instead, or a dog walker who can come in and break up your dog's day in the crate with exercise and a bathroom break.
And, yes, your dog's crate can also be used for time outs. This will not make the crate a negative, on the contrary, their crate is their safe space. As long as you aren't punishing your dog (yelling, grabbing them, shoving them into the crate roughly), then putting them in their crate for a time out won't change the positive way they view their crate. However, the key to time outs for puppies and dogs is to be able to put them into their time out immediately following whatever happened that earned them that time out in the first place. So, if your dog's crate is upstairs, in a bedroom, and the infraction was committed downstairs, then the crate might not be the optimal spot for the time out. Which brings me to exercise pens.
Exercise pens (x-pens) are wonderful for homes with puppies, in particular. You can set up an x-pen (or for smaller puppies and dogs, a doggie playpen) in the common room of your home, that is the space where your family spends most of their time. Your puppy can be put in that pen anytime you can't supervise them, but they are awake and active. You can put toys, puzzles, etc. in the play pen area with them and know that they are safe. Exercise pens are perfect for time outs as well since, again, they are centrally located. Just remember to pull out those toys, bones, and puzzles before placing your puppy in there for a time out. Any parent will tell you: A good time out means no TV, video games, phones, or books!
One more often overlooked use for an x-pen is in your yard. You can set up an x-pen in the area where you'd like your puppy to toilet, creating a well-defined bathroom area. You can make sure the zone you use is safe, meaning free of sprinkler heads, rocks, bark, acorns, and mushrooms before you place your puppy in there. The safety of the pen allows you to walk away, if you need to, knowing they won't wander off and hurt themselves. Once they've toileted in their designated potty area, you can return to praise them and let them out for some free time in the yard, supervised of course, since you never leave a puppy unsupervised in your yard ever!
My client lives in an apartment, so she doesn't have a lot of free space. We opted to use two crates for her puppy, placing one crate in her bedroom for naps and night time sleep and one, slightly larger crate in the corner of her kitchen for awake playtime and time outs, much as I described above for the x-pen or playpen, neither of which she has space for. Having two crates allows my client to reap the rewards of crate training despite her small living space.
We went over a lot more beyond crates during our Puppy 101 appointment, but I wanted to begin there because getting her puppy off to a great start with his house training and nap schedule was paramount to his success as a house dog and her success as a new dog owner!
As always, if you have questions about your pet's behavior, you know where to find me.
I have a crate in my office for Zelly when she's hanging out with me for the day. She'll go in there on her own when she wants to rest, as you can see, but it's also where she naps when I'm gone seeing clients. Here she is in her crate, using Desi's favorite crate pad and resting her head on Westley's favorite sleepy bear toy as a pillow. I feel like comfort pours out of those two things, straight from the lovely dogs who used them before her.